Northern Fury

An Alternative Cold War History

NATO Aircraft Carriers

10 July, 2018 | General News

undefined

ITS Giuseppe Garibaldi, FS Foch, and ESPS Príncipe Asturias 

In a previous Blog we discussed the disposition of the United States’ Navy’s (USN) aircraft carriers, and I said that most other nations operated their carriers differently from the US. This Blog will discuss the other NATO carriers existing in the 1994 setting of Northern Fury. Another Blog will discuss the Soviet version.

undefinedUSS John C. Stennis and HMS Illustrious

The United Kingdom with its three Invincible class ships (Invincible, Illustrious, and Ark Royal), France with two Clemenceau class (Clemenceau and Foch), Italy with the Giuseppe Garibaldi and Spain with the Príncipe de Asturias, are the only nations in NATO with Aircraft Carriers (CV) other than the US.  In comparing European CVs to those of the USN, it is probably easier to mention the similarities than to identify the differences: 1) They all operate aircraft, and 2) They don’t work alone. Beyond these two general statements, US and European carriers are completely different and fill largely different roles. A simple comparison of some data on each of the major ship classes shows that the USS Nimitz displaces over three times the volume of the French Clemenceau class and more than five times when compared to the more modern NATO ships. Statistics cannot tell the complete story, but the simple fact is that the NATO ships cannot, nor are they designed to do the same things as American carriers.

  USS Nimitz HMS Invincible  FS Clemenceau  ITS Giuseppe Garibaldi  ESPS Príncipe Asturias  
Displacement  100,000 Tons 22,000 Tons 32,780 Tons  13,850 Tons  16,700 Tons
Length 1,092 ft
332.8 m
689 ft
210 m
869 ft
265 m
 591 ft
180.2 m
 643 ft
195.9 m
Beam 252 ft
76.8 m
118.1 ft
36 m
168 ft
51.2 m
 110 ft
33.4 m
 80 ft
9.4 m
Draft 37 ft
11.3 m
24.6 ft
7.5 m
 28 ft
8.6 m
 27 ft
8.2 m
 31 ft
9.4 m
Aircraft 80-90 22-25 36-40   18  29
Range Unlimited 5,000 @18knts 7500@18knts   7000@20knts  6500@20knts
Crew ~5000 1,050 1,338   830  830
Speed 30+ 30  32  30  26
Age (in ’94) 19 yrs 9 yrs  33 yrs  9 yrs  6 yrs

So, what you might ask, can these small carriers do? Well the answer is quite a bit actually.

Command & Control (C2): While small when compared to the American fleet carriers, these ships are much larger than most other ships afloat, certainly in their own navies. Therefore, they can house an Admiral, his staff, a large communications centre, briefing areas and accommodation for liaison officers and visitors.

undefined

Airborne Early Warning (AEW): Although not as capable and far reaching as the American E-2C Hawkeye, all four countries operating the smaller carriers use helicopters in this role, three of them; Britain, Italy and Spain, use a version of the venerable Sea King while the French use an SA365 Dauphin for this task.

undefined

Royal Navy Sea King HAS.2 AEW

Area Anti-Submarine Warfare (ASW): One of the main roles of the smaller carriers is to command very capable, often multi-national ASW forces charged with ‘sanitizing’ an area before other units, such as USN Carriers or amphibious forces arrive. Indeed, all of the CVs mentioned above except the French Clemenceau class were originally intended for this role alone, until their nations purchased the Sea Harrier. Also, two ships not yet discussed are ideal for this task, the French Jeanne D’Arc which is largely a training ship by 1994 and the Italian Vittorio Veneto, are truly helicopter carriers (CVH) and not CVs. While the French use an SA.312 Super Frelon, the other three use a variant of the Sea King. Both helicopters have a dipping sonar.


undefinedFrench Navy SA 321G ASW

Limited Sea Control: All of these carriers can conduct Sea Control missions, both anti-air and anti-surface; but only against limited opposition. The key system for this task is the Sea Harrier for the Spanish, Italians and British Royal Navy while the French use a mix of Vietnam era F-8 Crusaders and slightly more modern Super Etendards. The Difficulty however is numbers. Depending on the task assigned, as few as six or as many as 14 aircraft can be carried on each of the British ships while the Italians and Spaniards routinely carry between six and 12. Although the French will carry 8-10 Crusaders and 15-16 Super Étendard , the age and limited survivability or flexibility of these aircraft present their own problems. In Northern Fury, the FS Foch is experimenting with US F-18s on loan when the war starts. Both the British and the French have an advantage in this role with their stand-off air-to-surface missiles, the Sea Eagle and the Exocet respectively.

 undefined

Spanish AV-8S Matador

Limited Strike: Both the Sea Harrier and the Super Étendard have the ability to conduct strike missions on land targets, but these have to be tempered with limited numbers and in some cases a restricted ammunition selection. The British are in the habit of using ground strike Harriers to augment their Sea Harriers for this role, while the Spanish ‘Matador’ is also quite capable, but the Italian Sea Harrier II has a very narrow munitions menu. The Super Étendard, particularly the upgraded (Modernisé) version introduced in the early 1990's have a wide selection but no precision guided land attack munitions.

undefined

French Super Étendard Modernisé

Amphibious Support: All of these carriers, including the two smaller CVH, are able to provide support for landing troops from the sea. Whether it is reconnaissance, strike, troop movement, air superiority, sea control or simply C2, these vessels are more suited to this role than the big American super-carriers. Their small size, agility and ability to get in close to the shore is a major asset, where the USN provides aircraft carrying amphibious ships to fulfill this task.

undefined

French CVH Jeanne d'Arc

Show of Force: Although restricted to peacetime operations, this is a critical element of deploying ships to trouble spots around the world. Although these are all small carriers, the only other CVs in the world are US, Soviet or ex British World War II antiques in Argentina, Brazil and India (with two, one of 1950’s vintage). So, small is good enough to exert a significant amount of pressure to resolve a situation in your favor as long as you're not going up against the big boys. The 1982 Falklands campaign bolstered this role considerably.

undefined

Italian CVH Vittorio Veneto

CV Battle Groups: These ships, though quite capable, cannot or should not operate alone. The same way the USN organizes a Battle Group of escorts around its carriers, any CV no matter how small will have an escort. Although they will vary widely and be much smaller for the CVHs, every carrier will usually be accompanied by an air defence ship and one or probably two ASW ships. France will use the Suffern class as the air defence shooter and the Tourville or Leygues class for ASW. Britain will almost always have at least one Type 42 and two Type 22 ships as escort. The Italians will use an Audace class for its air defence and Maestrale class for ASW. The Spanish will use a mix of Santa Maria and Baleares class frigates.

 

undefined

FS Clemenceau leading her battle group

These ships then, may be small in comparison to US Super Carriers but they are a significant investment in national capitol, training, commitment and strength. They are also powerful in their own right when used in the proper scenario. They are not meant to charge into heavily defended bastions; but they are meant to do many other jobs, thus allowing the concentration of US CV/CVNs to conduct high intensity power projection. 

undefined

ITS Giuseppe Garibaldi

undefined

ESPS Príncipe de Asturias

undefined

The Royal Navy's HMS Ark Royal